High Court Uber decision: What it means for medical practices and payroll tax
High Court Uber decision: What it means for medical practices and payroll tax
The High Court’s Uber decision reinforces the role of flow of funds in determining taxable wages for payroll tax purposes and clarifies how Australia’s payroll tax contractor provisions apply to intermediary payment arrangements. Medical, dental and allied health practices should consider what the reasoning means for their practitioner agreements, operating models and flow of patient funds.
On 4 November 2026, the High Court dismissed Uber’s appeal against an $81 million NSW payroll tax liability in Uber Australia Pty Ltd v Chief Commissioner of State Revenue [2026] HCA 40. The case concerned the contractor provisions in Division 7 of Part 3 of the Payroll Tax Act 2007 (NSW), including whether Uber’s arrangements with its drivers were ‘relevant contracts’ and whether amounts remitted to drivers were deemed wages for payroll tax purposes.
While the decision relates to Uber, its implications extend beyond the gig economy. For technology businesses operating platforms, marketplaces or other contractor-based models, it raises a broader commercial question: does the legal and tax structure reflect how the business actually operates?
What did the High Court decide?
The contractual and payment arrangements between Uber and its drivers were central to the case. The High Court considered whether Uber’s driver arrangements with drivers were "relevant contracts” under the NSW Payroll Tax legislation and whether payments remitted to drivers could therefore be treated as wages for payroll tax purposes. The High Court dismissed Uber’s appeal, confirming the application of the contractor provisions to Uber’s arrangements.
Where the contractor provisions apply, the legislation can treat the principal as an employer, the contractor as an employee and relevant payments as wages for payroll tax purposes.
For healthcare practices, the fact that professional services are ultimately provided to a patient does not necessarily prevent a practitioner from also providing services to the medical centre or service entity.
Revenue NSW’s medical services guidance states High Court decisions have confirmed that, depending on the arrangements, practitioner services may be provided to both the centre or clinic and patients.
Why is the decision relevant to medical practices?
Many healthcare practices operate under a services and facilities model. Practitioners may conduct their own professional businesses while a separate service entity provides consulting rooms, reception and administration, appointment and billing systems, equipment and other practice management services. The practitioner then pays the service entity a service or facilities fee.
Whether a practitioner operates an independent business is not the only consideration. Practices must also consider whether, under the contractual and operating arrangements, practitioners provide services to the medical centre or service entity, as well as to their patients.
Why the flow of patient funds matters
The flow of patient receipts is particularly important following the High Court’s decision.
Under Uber’s arrangements, fares were collected from riders by Uber as the driver’s payment collection agent. Uber deducted its service fee and other applicable amounts before remitting the balance to the driver. The High Court’s reasoning shows that using an intermediary payment collection arrangement does not, by itself, prevent amounts remitted to contractors from falling within the contractor provisions.
The reasoning may be relevant to healthcare arrangements where patient or Medicare receipts are collected by the medical practice or service entity before being remitted to practitioners.
The following examples show two possible payment flows. Their payroll tax treatment will depend on the complete contractual and operating arrangement.
Patient or Medicare → Medical practice/service entity → Service fee deducted → Balance remitted to practitioner
Where the practitioner arrangement is a relevant contract under s 32, amounts remitted by the medical practice or service entity to the practitioner may be deemed wages under s 35, subject to any applicable contractor exemption or other statutory relief.
The decision indicates that describing a practice as a collection agent, or characterising the remitted amount as the practitioner’s own money, may not be sufficient where the broader contractual arrangement falls within the relevant-contract provisions.
This should be distinguished from arrangements where patient fees are paid directly to the practitioner, with the practitioner separately paying a service or facilities fee to the medical practice:
Patient or Medicare → Practitioner → Service fee paid to medical practice
The appropriate payment model will depend on the practice’s full legal and commercial arrangements. Practices should obtain advice before changing existing contracts or payment processes.
Such an arrangement removes the clinic-to-practitioner remittance that was a significant feature of Uber’s payment model. However, changing the flow of funds alone should not be assumed to eliminate payroll tax exposure. The underlying contractual arrangement, relevant-contract provisions and any potentially applicable third-party payment provisions, including s 46, must still be considered.
Look beyond the wording of the agreement
Contractual labels alone do not determine the payroll tax treatment.
Describing an agreement as a ‘Services Agreement’ or ‘Facilities Agreement’, or describing a practitioner as independent, will not necessarily determine whether the relevant contract provisions apply.
When reviewing their arrangements, practices should consider:
- Who contracts with the patient for healthcare services
- What contractual obligations the practitioner owes to the service entity
- Who determines practitioner fees and appointment arrangements
- How practitioners are represented on the practice website and in marketing
- Who invoices patients and receives patient or Medicare payments
- How and by whom service fees are calculated and paid
- Who manages refunds and outstanding accounts
- Whether the day-to-day operation of the practice is consistent with the intended services and facilities model.
Not all medical practitioner arrangements are subject to payroll tax.
There may be significant differences between Uber’s rideshare model and a genuine services and facilities arrangement under which a service entity provides facilities and administrative support to practitioners carrying on independent professional businesses.
State and territory rules still matter
Payroll tax is administered at the state and territory level, and healthcare concessions and administrative treatments are not uniform across Australia.
For example, NSW provides specific payroll tax relief for qualifying General Practitioner (GP) contractor arrangements, including an ongoing rebate where prescribed billing requirements are satisfied. The relief is subject to detailed eligibility requirements and does not apply generally to all healthcare practitioners.
Western Australia operates differently, as payroll tax generally does not apply to payments made to contractors, provided the relationship between the principal and the worker is not considered to be one of employer and employee. Accordingly, reviewing the underlying agreement and the nature of the working relationship remains equally important.
Medical practices should therefore consider applicable state or territory concessions as part of any assessment of their payroll tax position.
What should medical practices do now?
Review practitioner agreements
Review services and facilities agreements to identify the obligations practitioners owe to the service entity and whether those obligations are consistent with the intended operating model.
Map the flow of funds
Map how patient and Medicare receipts are collected and distributed, including who receives and controls the funds, how service fees are deducted or paid, and whether amounts are remitted from the practice to practitioners.
Test how the model operates
Review appointment systems, websites, marketing, billing procedures, fee arrangements and practice policies against the intended independent practitioner model.
Align documentation and practice
Confirm that agreements, policies and supporting records reflect how the practice operates in reality.
Check state and territory concessions
Consider whether healthcare-specific exemptions, rebates or concessions are available before assessing potential historical or prospective payroll tax exposure.
How BDO can help
The High Court’s decision does not mean every service and facilities arrangement is subject to payroll tax. It does, however, reinforce the need to assess practitioner agreements, day-to-day practice operations and payment flows together and identify an arrangement that appropriately manages compliance while supporting commercial objectives, efficient administration and effective practitioner relationships.
BDO’s healthcare and employment tax specialists can assist medical, dental and allied health practices to review their existing arrangements, assess potential payroll tax exposure and identify available state or territory concessions. Where changes to contractual arrangements are required, we can work alongside the practice’s legal advisers.
Contact us to discuss how the decision may affect your practitioner arrangements.
This publication has been carefully prepared, but is general commentary only. This publication is not legal or financial advice and should not be relied upon as such. The information in this publication is subject to change at any time and therefore we give no assurance or warranty that the information is current when read. The publication cannot be relied upon to cover any specific situation and you should not act, or refrain from acting, upon the information contained therein without obtaining specific professional advice. Please contact the BDO member firms in Australia to discuss these matters in the context of your particular circumstances.
Each BDO member firm in Australia, their partners and/or directors, employees and agents do not give any warranty as to the accuracy, reliability or completeness of information contained in this publication nor do they accept or assume any liability or duty of care for any loss arising from any action taken or not taken by anyone in reliance on the information in this publication or for any decision based on it, except in so far as any liability under statute cannot be excluded.
A.C.N. 050 110 275 Ltd ABN 77 050 110 275, an Australian company limited by guarantee, is a member of BDO International Ltd, a UK company limited by guarantee, and forms part of the international BDO network of independent member firms.
BDO is the brand name for the BDO network and for each of the BDO member firms.
© 2026 A.C.N. 050 110 275 Ltd. All rights reserved.
